Monday, 12 March 2012

M-learning pedagogy or digigogy?


Digigogy Images 
























Digigogy images taken from: http://www.flickr.com/photos/grade6kms/5103565561/

With so many devices being developed and launched it is hard to keep up with what tools are available. When thinking about including some form of m-learning into teaching and learning, it is easy to start with the device and ask what can be done with it. It is also easy to think about including a device in a lesson simply to engage learners, rather than considering whether the activity is enhanced by using a device (Brooks-Young 2010). Fisher (2010) talks about the need to create strong pedagogical frameworks when choosing a device or tool to use as opposed to "..inserting it into a lesson plan in a surface level way".

Caudill (2007) suggests that the frameworks and theories in m-learning are essentially the same as in e-learning since both are about blending and integrating technology into learning and teaching to enhance a broader learning experience.

However, the Mobilearn Conference in 2004 (Mellow 2005) discussed the idea that m-learning is in fact a sub-set of e-learning. It suggests that m-learning should be considered in a blended learning context since m-devices are rarely used to teach a whole program of study or to deliver an entire course or module.

To break down the idea of 'good' m-learning practice, Sanchez-Terrell (2011) looks at what makes it effective, which is when learners...
  • choose the content
  • interact with...objects and experiences
  • are moving around with the device
  • are motivated to expand learning outside the classroom
  • work collaboratively
Further, Float Learning suggest that the basics of good m-learning include:
  • content which is "bite-sized, train-stop sized, waiting room sized"
  • "may or may not have an assessment component but is measurable"
  • "easy to use..contextual"
Mellow (2005) similarly talks about the size of the learning in that m-learning devices are often good for 'chunking' content into 'bite-sized' portions that can be accessed and completed in a relatively short time. Mellow also discusses "'knowledge bites' that offer flexibility of time, place and pace" (p2)

In researching m-learning pedagogy, I came across the idea of 'Digigogy'. Mike Fisher (2010) talks about the emergence of digigogy and explains this is the crossover between technology and pedagogy.

 "Where pedagogy is about methods to instruct, Digigogy is about those methods, but with a technological frame. From hardware to software, from tech ed theory to application, Digigogy is about reframing our methods in the future of instruction. The new way of learning is a complete tear down and rebuild of traditional teaching, where learning is a joint effort and roles are reborn. Beyond the desks...beyond the walls...beyond the school. The new classroom is orbital, and scenic, and here" 

Mike Fisher, http://digigogy.blogspot.com/2010/05/digigogical-upgrade.html

                      Open publication - Free publishing - More web2.0

The idea of a 'digigogy' is interesting and seems relevant to the changes taking place in education and learning. There is a shift towards collaborative work, sharing within learning communities, and personal project-based, practical experiences. As these changes develop further in the future so should our pedagogy that underpins education. A 21st Century pedagogy is outlined below:


Finally, since what we ask the students to do and how we allow them to do it is changing, will the focus of our assessment change? An interesting point discussed by Devaney (2008, cited in Brooks-Young 2010) highlights a pilot program in Australia which, rather than assessing the students' ability to memorise information, looked at their ability to find it. With information all around us via m-devices, will the future of education shift from memorising to collating or currating?




Brooks-Young. S (ed) (2010) Teaching with the tools kids really use. Corwin Press.

Caudill. J (2007) The growth of M-learning and the Growth of Mobile Computing: Parallel Development. International review of research in open and distance Learning 8.2 works/bepress.com/jason-caudill/4


Mellow. P (2005) The media generation: Maximising learning by getting mobile. ASCILITE 2005 Conference. www.ascilite.org.au/conferences/brisbane05/blogs/proceedings/53_Mellow.pdf

Sanchez-Terrell. S (2011) Effective mobile learning: 50+ quick tips and resources. http://scribd.com/mobile/documents/67369598




BYOD: bring your own device

More and more learners are accessing data through m-devices so it is important as educators to think about how we might engage our learners using these methods that are part of their everyday lives. However, in many places m-learning devices such a mobile phones or iPads are often still banned in classrooms and can be seen as 'distractors' to learning in the classroom. In reading educator's blogs, you are likely to find a variety of opinions on m-devices in the classroom from those that ban them, to those who fully embrace them. As an educator somewhere in the middle, I'm keen to find out more about how other teachers incorporate them into their classroom teaching and the frameworks and methodology that they use for this.

Currently, there is a lot of discussion of BYOD: Bring Your Own Device, not just in education but in business too. An interesting introduction to this in teaching is the blog http://adifference.blogspot.com/2011/07/how-would-i-prepare-to-teach-byod-class.html where the preparation for teaching a byod class is discussed and tools are suggested. 

There are pros and cons of BYOD and many parents and teachers alike worry about the control and monitoring aspects of it. Would this introduction of more technology to the classroom cause disruption? What are the restrictions of students videoing teachers and uploading to sites such as youtube? Would students become targets of bullying or theft? (Guardian 2009). However, regardless of a ban on devices in the classroom, students still use them; As Gliksman (2012) points out in his presentation 'Building an effective school BYOD', an ACSD study found that in schools that ban m-devices, 63% of students use them anyway. So would it be better if we included them in our teaching?

Marcos and McLeod (2011) would answer yes: "...I can find no sound pedagogical, social or practical reason for restricting the use of  technical devices. Telling the students what devices they can use and when, is like telling them what brand of pencil they can use and when".

His conclusion from a year of including technology into the curriculum is that there is actually less distraction happening in the classroom than without technology. Students are focused on the tasks and are in charge of their own learning. Gliksman seems to agree by advocating that learners are more engaged and motivated. However, he goes on to highlight the challenges surround BYOD and the need careful consideration and planning.

These considerations might include:
         security
         access
         control and authentication
         cost and accessibility

As Caudill (2007) points out, it is also important to consider equality of access and that it is "..dangerous to assume all learners have access [to m-devices]" (p.5). In setting up a BYOD session, learners need to be the centre and their skills in using and access to a device need to be considered. Interestingly though, Nielson (2011) talks about how students are 'bridging the connectivity divide; how students in lower income families where there is no computer at home are often getting on online through their phones. Her article "7 Myths about BYOD debunked" explains that BYOD does not create or deepen the digital divide, as it still exists whether m-devices are used in schools or not. She suggests that schools should not stop those who do have devices from accessing learning through them but rather support and provide for those that don't to extend all learning.

Caudill. J (2007) The growth of M-learning and the Growth of Mobile Computing: Parallel Development. International review of research in open and distance Learning 8.2 works/bepress.com/jason-caudill/4

Gliksman. S (2012) Building an Effective School BYOD http://www.slideshare.net/samgliksman/building-an-effective-school-byod-plan

Nielsen. L (2011) 7 Myths About BYOD Debunked http://thejournal.com/Articles/2011/11/09/7-BYOD-Myths.aspx?Page=1
Marcos. E and McLeod. S (2011) Let Them BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) www.ovenell-carter.com/let-them-byod

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

M-learning infographic: smartphone usage


Mobile Studying & Online Flashcards on Smartphones [Infographic]
Via: STUDYBLUE.com

This interesting infographic shows the results of a StudyBlue survey of nearly 1m students in the autumn semester 2011 and is combined with information from the University of Colorado.

Interestingly, it states that learners using an m-learning device check their progress 3 times as often as other learners. Could this suggest they rely on quick feedback to make decisions about their learning path?

It is also interesting to see where users are accessing learning, from bed or bathroom to commute or waiting in a queue. The study found most users (75%) were accessing learning on their commute.

Further, the study of 517 smartphone users at the University of Colorado (Dean 2010) found that "when students choose to consume different types of media on their smartphones, they tend to do so in small amounts".  Their statistics show that the majority of users accessed less than 1 minute of a video news report or read less than the first 3 paragraphs of text based news articles, suggesting that users are 'dipping in and out' of smartphone media. Dean's analysis of this concludes that while short attention span consumption of data is also seen in other platforms, such as PC internet use, further study is needed to evaluate the user's interest in a topic and their consumption of smartphone data. 

Dean (2010) also found that users are often multi-tasking and accessing data from smartphones while listening to music, shopping or when they are idle. It is suggested that these short periods could be used for scanning news or for bookmarking content to look at later on, when the user can focus more.

The most popular types of information access were email and text messaging, the least popular being audio podcasts and e-readers/ online book content.

A study of social media usage on m-devices (Bloch 2010) is shown below:

This study also showed that in 2010 there were 100 million active users of facebook who were accessing the site through an m-device. It is interesting to note that the study found that the largest percentages of users networking on social sites vie their mobile were aged between 25-34 and 35-55 years old.

Further, it showed that more users are socialising using their m-device than are using a a non-mobile device (such as a PC).

Those accessing Twitter from an m-device, for example, increased between 2009 and 2010 by approximately 3,600. Twitter, which was apparently based on the idea of a text message, is therefore already  familiar in content to the user.



Bloch. E (2010) How are mobile phones changing social media? http://www.flowtown.com/blog/how-are-mobile-phones-changing-social-media

Dean. J (2010) Smartphone User Survey: A glimpse into the mobile lives of college students http://testkitchen.colorado.edu/projects/reports/smartphone/smartphone-survey/

Klundt. C (2011) Infographic: Studying Online Flashcards in Smartphones: http://www.studyblue.com/about/2011/11/infographic-studying-online-flashcards-on-smartphones/




Friday, 2 March 2012

Wiffiti & TextTheMob

Following on from the Tremblay's study discussed in 'More than Mobile + Learning', I came across these audience response tools while researching developments in m-learning.
   

Wiffiti seems like a great way to use mobiles in the classroom and could have some blended learning uses too. Students can text their answers from their mobile phones and their texts appear on the whiteboard or screen. Currently, it is being modified to allow for moderation and 'blocking' of certain content which would be essential in most classroom settings. 


On a similar theme, Text the Mob allows you to poll your students, collect answers or even questions by a similar process - students use their mobiles to text. The free version allows you to post up to 3 questions and have up to 50 response particpants at an event. There are more features available in their paid packages.